Could the Seattle Mariners be eyeing CJ Abrams as their next second baseman? It’s a move that could reshape their infield, but it’s also one that divides opinions. As the Mariners continue their search for a reliable starter at second base, rumors are swirling about their interest in the Washington Nationals’ 25-year-old infielder. But here’s where it gets controversial: Abrams, despite his potential, has been labeled by some as an underachiever in his MLB career so far. So, why would Seattle take a chance on him?
The Mariners are no strangers to exploring trade options, having been in talks with multiple teams across the league. However, a recent development in the National League might have them reevaluating their strategy. According to The Athletic’s Andrew Baggarly, the San Francisco Giants were rebuffed in their attempt to acquire Abrams as their second baseman. This raises the question: Are the Mariners considering a similar move, or will they pass on the opportunity?
And this is the part most people miss: Abrams’ inconsistent performance and defensive struggles have made him a polarizing figure. In 2025, he posted a .257 batting average with 19 home runs, 60 RBIs, and 31 stolen bases—numbers that could bolster Seattle’s lineup. Yet, his defense remains a concern. Two seasons ago, he was ranked among the worst full-time shortstops in the league, with a -17 Outs Above Average (OAA) and -13 Fielding Run Value. Last year, he tied his career-worst 22 errors and managed only a .962 fielding percentage. So, while his bat shows promise, his glove leaves much to be desired.
Seattle would likely offer less for Abrams than they reportedly proposed to the St. Louis Cardinals for Brendan Donovan. His unproven track record at second base and inconsistent stats make him a risky bet. Plus, the Mariners aren’t expected to part with their top prospects in any deal. But could Abrams be the missing piece they’re looking for, or is he a gamble they shouldn’t take?
Here’s the bold truth: Abrams has shown flashes of brilliance but has yet to put it all together. MLB Trade Rumors notes that he’s been an above-average hitter, with a .252/.315/.433 slash line over the past two seasons, 39 home runs, and 62 stolen bases. However, his second-half slumps and defensive liabilities have prevented him from reaching his All-Star potential. Analysts suggest he might fare better at second base or even center field, but that remains to be seen.
So, what do you think? Is CJ Abrams worth the risk for the Mariners, or should they look elsewhere? Let us know in the comments—this is one debate that’s sure to spark some heated discussions!
